Best 9 Substitutes For Pickle Relish In Potato Salad

Using sweet pickle relish is a straightforward way to add flavor and texture to otherwise flavorless dishes. But what if you run out of pickle relish in the middle of making the dish, and the recipe calls for it?

What would be the most suitable alternative to  pickle relish to use? Alternatives to sweet pickle relish that are delicious and easy to use include green olives, capers, freeze-dried dill, and chopped dill pickles. In some recipes, celery, cucumbers, and green bell peppers are also sometimes called for as ingredients.

This article discusses the most excellent sweet pickle relish alternatives and tips on utilizing them. If you don’t have pickles on hand, I’ll also show you how to choose the right substitute for specific meals.

Uses And Pairings for Pickle Relish

The main uses of pickle relish are as follows. One of the most common relish dish is sweet pickle relish, produced from pickles, bell peppers, onions, sugar, and vinegar. To taste, other ingredients can be added, such as celery seeds, dill seeds, mustard, and garlic.

Relish is generally consumed with bland or dry foods. A simple and quick method to give your favorite foods a ton of flavor is to use store-bought pickle relish.

There are other uses for pickle relish and a topping for hot dogs, burgers, and sandwiches. This is how pickle relish is used in delicious dishes.

As A Tasty Complement To Salads

Substitute For Pickle Relish In Potato Salad

The flavor of pickle relish is potent. It has a sweet and salty flavor. This green condiment has a richness added by its gentle taste and sharp flavor.  Avoiding taste collisions when combining pickle relish with other foods is crucial. This is why meat, deviled eggs, cheese, and crackers are frequently served with pickle relish.

With this, you should frequently confirm whether adding it would improve the primary tastes or upset the dish’s balance.

The Top 7 Pickle Relish Alternatives

Numerous items can be used in place of pickle relish. Naturally, not every product can deliver tastes as distinct as your beloved pickles. However, a carefully picked alternative will undoubtedly give the salad, sauce, or dip you are cooking hints of taste and texture.

See also  Can You Freeze Bone Broth? Truth Revealed!

Sandwiches, hot dogs, and hamburgers will only taste bland if the pickle relish is skipped. On the other hand, substituting another item for the relish will unquestionably enhance their flavor.

1. Dill Pickles

Substitute For Pickle Relish In Potato Salad

The closest replacement for pickle relish may be chopped or minced dill pickle. Cucumbers are similar to dill in some way, but the outer texture is what distinguishes them. The flavor of dill pickles will still be similar to that of pickle relish and you may not notice the difference in a meal.

Dill pickles are crisp, they have a strong flavor with a sweet and sour taste. Any recipe that requires pickle relish can be substituted with chopped dill pickles. Additionally, you can include them in your hot dogs and hamburgers. However, you might have to skip the sweetness.

2. Freeze-Dried Dill

Substitute For Pickle Relish In Potato Salad

Dill gives food a freshness that no other herb can match. It’s qualities are elevated by its zesty flavors and provide a lot of depth through the green undertones. When compared to fresh dill, freeze-dried dill lasts a lot longer. A tablespoon of chopped fresh dill is equivalent to one frozen-dried dill.

Instead of pickle relish, you can substitute freeze-dried dill in recipes that call for a flavorful burst of freshness. Fish, chicken, eggs, vegetables like potatoes, zucchini, carrots, and dried dill go nicely together. Swap out the pickle relish for freeze-dried dill in dips, sauces, and dressings.

3. Green Olives

Substitute For Pickle Relish In Potato Salad

The flavor profile of green olives is particularly distinctive. Compared to typical black olives, they have a more vibrant flavor. Green olives have a little nutty and tart flavor profile and are acidic. Green olives aren’t a favorite of everyone. However, you may undoubtedly cut some of them and use them in place of pickle relish if you do.

Salads and dips benefit significantly from the inclusion of green olives. You may add some to your sandwiches and wraps for extra flavor.

4. Capers

Substitute For Pickle Relish In Potato Salad

The flavor of capers is tart and lemony. They have an olive-like taste and are also salty. You can undoubtedly replace capers for pickle relish if the recipe needs the tanginess and balance that the relish provides.

Without adding as much texture, capers can also give the sour, vinegary flavor that sweet pickle relish does. Capers are excellent in marinades and salad dressings. Additionally, you may use them in pasta salads, frequently improved with sweet pickle relish.

See also  Can Sausage Be Pink? Fully Answered!

5. Green Bell Peppers

Substitute For Pickle Relish In Potato Salad

Pickle relish is frequently used to give food more texture. If you want to add some crunch and color to your sandwiches, salads, or dips but are missing delicious pickle relish, use chopped green peppers.

Green bell peppers have a grassy undertone and a mild bitterness. The best ones are crisp and juicy as well. Green bell peppers, which lack acidity and have robust flavors, might assist you in creating balance in your recipes.

6. Celery

Substitute For Pickle Relish In Potato Salad


Are you interested in learning how raw celery stalks can replace pickle relish? There are probably a few celery stalks in your refrigerator if you enjoy drinking green smoothies. Here is what you can do, though. With celery stalks instead of cucumber slices, you may quickly prepare your own sweet pickle relish dish.

You now have a tasty alternative to pickle relish for sandwiches, hot dogs, and hamburgers. You must combine minced garlic and onion with wine, vinegar and olive oil to marinade the chopped or sliced celery stalks. Add capers, herbs, and salt & pepper to taste.

7. Cucumber


Best 9 Substitutes For Pickle Relish In Potato Salad

Cucumbers don’t have a robust flavor, as we all know. However, they are excellent at adding texture and crunch. Cucumbers can be used as-is in some recipes that call for pickle relish if you have them but don’t have the time to get the pickles.

Cucumbers go well in burgers, sandwiches, salads, sauces, and dips. With a bit of that chilly, crisp flavor, they will offer a lovely textural note.

8. Piccalilli Peppers

Substitute For Pickle Relish In Potato Salad

Piccalilli relish is a condiment with a mustard basis that has calming flavors. It serves as a condiment like pickle relish. For this reason, piccalilli relish makes an excellent pickles alternative. Piccalilli relish pairs nicely with other strong-tasting meals thanks to its sharp, tangy, vinegary, and head-clearing flavor.

Pickle relish and piccalilli relish are stylistically related. Because of this, the same amount of piccalilli and pickle relish can be utilized when preparing a dish. This alternative is excellent for hot dogs and hamburgers.

9. Bread and Butter Pickles

Substitute For Pickle Relish In Potato Salad

The genre of sweet pickles includes a wide variety of pickles, such as bread and butter pickles. Bread and butter pickles, often known as sweet and sour pickles, are more precious than other conventional sweet pickles but not as sweet as they are. Therefore, pickle relish could be replaced with bread & butter pickles.

See also  Can You Freeze Chicken Salad With Greek Yogurt? Explained!

Jars of bread and butter pickles are frequently available in stores. If they are chopped or ground, they make excellent replacements. This guarantees consistency in appearance, resembling jarred sweet pickle relish.

You can get the sweetness and tanginess you want in pickles relished from bread and butter pickles. They are also suitable for topping burgers and other hearty meals. Pickles can be swapped for bread and butter pickles in a 1:1 ratio.

How to Pick a Replacement for Pickle Relish

The primary consideration while looking for a sweet pickle relish replacement is what else you have at home. If the selection of ingredients is limited, you must choose something with flavor notes that are even vaguely close, or you must altogether avoid the product.

Consider the dish’s purpose while selecting a replacement for pickle relish. Do you require the relish’s lovely pickle texture? A finely textured vegetable like pickle relish can significantly improve something in dishes, like essential hot dogs.

Choose replacements you can mince to make them feel like pickle relish if the texture is one of the key reasons you need it. Choose an ingredient with mild tart flavor notes if you want the tartness of pickle relish. If you can reach the appropriate balance, you can replace various components for the sweet-salty flavor of the pickles.

You won’t have any issue replacing pickle relish if you use it as a topping for hot dogs and hamburgers. However, as we’ve already indicated, pickle relish substitutes can be used to make salad dressings, sauces, and dips.

You might be surprised to see pickle relish on the ingredient list of a sauce or salad you are making if you don’t like it, and it doesn’t typically sit in your refrigerator with condiments like ketchup and mayonnaise.

Knowing what to use in place of pickle relish will be helpful in this situation.


That’s it! Now you have the ultimate list of other vegetables you can use as substitutes for pickle relish. This means you won’t have to involve yourself in too much stress when next you’re cooking and you can’t get pickle relish. Please leave a comment below, I’d love to hear from you.

Leave a Comment

error: Content is protected !!